| James Connell | 1965 |
| Andrew Huston | 1965 |
| John Alter | 1968 |
| Daniel Balistreri | 1968 |
| Michael Durant | 1970 |
| Jeffery Story | 1970 |
| James Behnke | 1971 |
| Dale Burkhart | 1971 |
| Joseph D’Amico | 1972 |
| James Kosanke | 1973 |
| Jeff Nabarek | 1973 |
| Paul Strvlowski | 1973 |
| John D | 1974 |
| William Bremberger | 1976 |
| Mark Van Horn | 1976 |
| Edson Smith | 1978 |
| William Bartlett | 1980 |
| Ron Sullivan | 1984 |
| Matthew Peirce | 1987 |
| Anthony Susa | 1989 |
| Benjamin Peirce | 1990 |
| Michael Yarger | 1991 |
| Ryan Akers | 1992 |
| Mark Eldredge | 1992 |
| Tom Taylor | 1992 |
| Kevin Meyer | 1994 |
| Corey Strahm | 1994 |
| Jason Eldredge | 1996 |
| Christopher Lentzke | 1996 |
| Nicholas Ciesinski | 1997 |
| John Cooney | 1997 |
| James Miswald | 1997 |
| Benjamin Bausch | 2001 |
| Brady Mayer | 2001 |
| Jason Lentzke | 2002 |
| Stephen Lovas | 2003 |
| Christopher Lovas | 2004 |
| Eric Hill | 2005 |
| Brennan Rowe | 2005 |
| John Lovas | 2007 |
| Ryan Erkes | 2008 |
| Matthew Kremer | 2008 |
| Nicholas Garcia | 2009 |
| Gary Bjerke | 2010 |
| Andrew Keal | 2010 |
| Joseph Keal | 2010 |
| Reed Erkes | 2011 |
| Roberto Medina | 2011 |
| Matthew Schulze | 2011 |
| Adam Bjerke | 2012 |
| Peter Keal | 2012 |
| Steven Kelly | 2012 |
| Thomas Witzel | 2012 |
| Trevor Norton | 2012 |
| Griffin Bennett | 2013 |
| Lucas Harding | 2013 |
| Bradley Schwab | 2013 |
| Samuel Blomberg | 2014 |
| Mitchell Muffler | 2014 |
| Nicholas Schulze | 2014 |
| Thomas Abts | 2015 |
| Daniel Kelly | 2015 |
| Brett Otto | 2015 |
| Alexander Fusco | 2016 |
| Henry Laste | 2016 |
| Douglas Muffler | 2016 |
| Jared Coonan | 2017 |
| Avery Marzolf | 2017 |
| Spencer Muffler | 2017 |
| Chaz Hinn | 2018 |
| Danny Brand | 2018 |
| Max Schwab | 2018 |
| Sam Tackett | 2018 |
| Andrew Muffler | 2019 |
| Sean Oliver | 2019 |
| Sam Ewert | 2020 |
| Christopher Abts | 2020 |
| Logan Flanagan | 2020 |
| Luke Tackett | 2021 |
| Justin Wiggins | 2021 |
| Dominic H. | 2021 |
| Alex White | 2022 |
| Ethan Flanagan | 2022 |
| Jackson Motley | 2022 |
| Mark Schoeppel | 2022 |
| Michael Stadler | 2022 |
This list is every Eagle Scout we have found a record for.